Gold & Silver

Tastes change. Styles change. Priorities change. There may come a time when the jewelry you have is no longer representative of the person you are today. Perhaps it’s time to celebrate the freedom of a big life change, or it may simply be time to make room for new treasures.

Learn More

Costume Jewelry

Do you have a box of old costume jewelry sitting around? We buy vintage costume jewelry for resale, crafts and charity. Why not turn those old clip on earrings into cash! Bring in your unwanted jewelry, even if it's broken. Malena uses it for her show on Mass Appeal and donated a portion of sales to Samaritan's Purse.

Learn more


Do you have an old fur you no longer wear? We buy furs and recycle them into hand bags, vests, pillows and teddy bears. We believe in respecting the life of the animal by using the vintage furs we have and not contributing to the production of new fur. A portion of fur sales goes to the local humane society. We appreciate your donation.

Learn More

Welcome to Fancy That Antiques! We buy full vintage costume jewelry, furs, gold and silver, pocket watches, old clocks, antiques and much more. We understand many things have sentimental value and we will work with you to find the best way to serve your needs. We will appraise your jewelry and antiques and help you find the best way to sell your precious things.
We love our community and our neighbors! As they say, one man’s trash is another man’s treasure. We are happy to help you sell your valuables. If we choose not to buy your items, we can help you find the best way to sell them. We have auction contacts, estate sale reps and other valuable information we are happy to share with you.

Here’s a list of items we are currently interested in BUYING:
Vintage & Antique Jewelry (Both costume and fine)
Tea Cups
Tea Sets
Advertising Signs
Vintage Video Games
Military Memorabilia
Men’s Watches
Christian Relics such as last rites boxes, crucifixes, Mother Mary and Jesus statues
Bird Cages
Feel free to call, text or email us with your questions. With our new mailing list, we do not sell or share your information. We also do not participate in ads! Thank you for your patience as we continue to update our website.
Fancy That Antiques
2805 Boston Rd. Wilbraham, MA 01095